Skip to content

The Abstraction of Money: How Digital Payments Are Changing the Way We Spend

How payment technology, behavioural design and artificial intelligence are reshaping consumer decisions and financial awareness.

Money has become increasingly digital. We pay for coffee with a phone, subscribe to services with a click, buy products online, and manage transactions without handling physical cash.

The transaction may take seconds. The financial commitment, however, can extend far beyond the moment of purchase.

This transformation has changed more than payment mechanics. It has also changed the environment in which consumers make spending decisions. The relationship between purchasing and paying is becoming less tangible, while digital platforms increasingly influence what we see, how choices are presented and how easily we complete a transaction.

Understanding how we spend therefore requires us to look beyond individual habits. We need to examine the psychology of paying, the design of digital environments, the commercial incentives behind them, the policies intended to protect consumers and the growing role of artificial intelligence in financial decision-making.

For individuals seeking to retain more of their income and build financial capacity, these developments matter. Money may have become less visible, but its economic consequences remain tangible.

1. Money has changed. Has the experience of spending changed with it?

Consider a familiar experience.

You purchase a coffee using contactless payment. There is no need to open a wallet, count banknotes or receive change. A small movement of your phone or card completes the transaction.

Later, you purchase something online. Your payment details are already stored. A click confirms the order.

You may also have subscriptions that renew automatically, payments deducted from your account and purchases divided into instalments.

Each transaction is convenient. Yet the experience of spending is different from physically handing over money.

Historically, cash provided a visible representation of an exchange. You could see the amount in your wallet decrease. With digital payments, the transaction is recorded electronically, but the physical experience of money leaving your possession is reduced.

This distinction matters because spending is not simply a mathematical exercise. It is also a behavioural process.

The way we pay can influence how we experience the financial cost of a purchase. The speed, visibility and convenience of a transaction can affect the attention we give to it.

Digital payments are not inherently irresponsible, nor does using cash automatically lead to better financial decisions. Electronic payments offer considerable advantages, including convenience, accessibility, speed and transaction records.

The question is not whether digital payments are good or bad. It is how the changing experience of payment interacts with the decisions we make.

2. The psychology of paying: Why does spending feel different?

Behavioural economics helps explain why the act of paying can influence the experience of consumption.

One important concept is the pain of paying.

In their 1998 paper, The Red and the Black: Mental Accounting of Savings and Debt, Drazen Prelec and George Loewenstein examined the psychological relationship between consumption and payment.

Purchasing something can provide immediate satisfaction. Paying for it introduces a financial cost. These two experiences are connected, but they do not necessarily carry the same psychological weight.

The discomfort associated with paying can influence how consumers evaluate a purchase. When payment is less visible or psychologically separated from consumption, the financial cost may receive less attention at the moment of decision.

This is particularly relevant in a digital environment where payment can become almost instantaneous.

Another important concept is mental accounting: the way people organise and evaluate money in different psychological categories.

People may treat money differently depending on where it comes from, what they intend to use it for or how they receive it. A salary, a bonus, a tax refund and a credit limit may all be viewed differently, even though each has an economic value.

Payment mechanisms can also influence how people remember spending.

In his 2001 study, Effects of Payment Mechanism on Spending Behavior, Dilip Soman examined the role of payment rehearsal and immediacy. His research explored how the characteristics of a payment method influence the recollection of previous expenditure and subsequent purchase intentions.

These findings help explain why the experience of spending cannot be separated from the experience of paying.

Other behavioural influences also matter:

  • Present bias: The immediate benefit of a purchase can receive more attention than its future financial implications.
  • Inertia: People may continue paying for services or subscriptions because reviewing or cancelling them requires effort.
  • Choice overload: A large number of options can make comparison and evaluation more difficult.
  • Social influence: Advertising, recommendations and social expectations can shape perceptions of what is desirable or affordable.

None of these behaviours is unique to digital payments. However, digital environments can change the conditions in which they operate.

3. The cashless effect: What does the research tell us?

The relationship between payment methods and spending has been examined in behavioural and consumer research for decades.

One of the most comprehensive contributions is the 2024 meta-analysis by Lachlan Schomburgk, Alex Belli and Arvid O. I. Hoffmann, published in the Journal of Retailing.

Their study, Less Cash, More Splash? A Meta-Analysis on the Cashless Effect, synthesised 392 effect sizes from 71 papers.

The researchers found a small but statistically significant cashless effect: consumers tended to spend more when using cashless payment methods than when using cash.

However, the findings were not uniform across all circumstances. The effect was stronger in conspicuous consumption situations and weaker in pro-social consumption situations. The researchers also found that the effect had weakened over time.

This qualification is important. It suggests that the relationship between payment methods and spending is influenced by context and may change as consumers become more familiar with cashless transactions.

The research does not establish that every digital payment leads to higher spending, or that cash is always the better payment method.

Instead, it provides evidence that the method of payment can be one factor influencing consumer behaviour.

For financial management, the implication is worth considering: a transaction can be convenient and efficient while still deserving the same attention as any other financial commitment.

4. Designed to spend: The architecture of digital consumption

The payment method is only one part of the story. The environment in which the purchase takes place also matters.

Digital platforms are designed environments. The arrangement of information, the number of steps required to complete a transaction, the visibility of prices and the presentation of alternatives can all influence consumer decisions.

This is known as choice architecture: the way choices are organised and presented can affect how people respond to them.

Consider some familiar features of online purchasing:

One-click purchasing

Stored payment details and simplified checkout processes reduce the effort required to complete a transaction. This can make shopping more efficient, but it can also reduce the time available to reconsider a purchase.

Saved payment credentials

When payment details are stored, consumers do not need to enter them for every transaction. The convenience is clear. At the same time, the purchase may require fewer deliberate steps.

Subscriptions and automatic renewals

Recurring payments provide continuity and convenience. However, consumers may overlook renewals, underestimate the cumulative cost of several subscriptions or postpone cancellation.

Buy Now, Pay Later

Instalment payment arrangements can make purchases more accessible by spreading payments over time. But the immediate purchase price may receive more attention than the total financial commitment, the repayment schedule or the implications of managing several instalments simultaneously.

Personalised recommendations

Digital platforms can use consumer data and algorithms to recommend products, services and offers. Personalisation can make product discovery more relevant, but it can also increase exposure to commercial prompts.

These features are not necessarily manipulative. Their effects depend on how they are designed, presented and used.

The distinction is between design that helps people make informed choices and design that exploits behavioural tendencies or makes it harder to exercise those choices.

The latter is often associated with dark patterns: interface designs that manipulate, mislead or obstruct consumers.

For example, a platform might make subscribing straightforward but make cancellation difficult. A free trial may require payment details and convert automatically into a paid subscription. An interface may give prominence to the option that benefits the seller while making alternatives less visible.

The European Commission’s 2024 Digital Fairness Fitness Check examined these and other problematic practices in digital markets. It identified concerns involving dark patterns, unfair personalisation, misleading pricing, subscription practices and design features that encourage excessive engagement or spending.

The EU’s Digital Services Act also addresses manipulative online interface design. Article 25 prohibits online platforms from designing, organising or operating their interfaces in ways that deceive or manipulate users or otherwise materially distort their ability to make free and informed decisions, subject to the provision’s scope and legal qualifications.

This brings an important economic question into the discussion:

When consumer behaviour is influenced by the design of the environment, how much responsibility should rest with the individual, and how much with the organisations designing that environment?

5. When algorithms and artificial intelligence enter the spending relationship

Digital platforms do not simply process transactions. They increasingly influence what consumers see, how products are presented and which choices receive attention.

Recommendation systems can personalise offers and content based on browsing behaviour, previous purchases and other available data.

Artificial intelligence is expanding these capabilities. It can support product recommendations, customer interactions, targeted marketing and increasingly sophisticated forms of personalisation.

This introduces another dimension to consumer behaviour: decisions are not always made from a neutral set of options. The information presented to an individual may already have been selected, ranked or personalised.

The implications extend beyond shopping.

People are also turning to generative AI for help with personal financial decisions.

A 2026 study by Tae-Young Pak, published in the Journal of Behavioural and Experimental Finance, examined how 2,170 adults in South Korea aged 25–59 used large language models for personal financial management.

The study found that 67.8% of respondents had used an LLM for at least one financial task. Common applications included stock investment, savings planning, budget management and tax planning. Respondents used these tools as on-demand tutors, search engines and, in some cases, sources of personalised advice and emotional support.

The study also found differences in use across demographic groups: usage was higher among men, younger adults, people with higher education and full-time workers.

These findings are from a particular population and should not be generalised automatically to all countries or consumer groups. Nevertheless, they illustrate how conversational AI is becoming part of the personal finance environment.

This development presents both opportunities and questions.

AI can help explain financial concepts, organise information, compare alternatives and make financial knowledge more accessible. It can help people formulate questions and explore decisions they might otherwise find difficult to approach.

However, accessibility is not the same as accuracy, suitability or professional accountability.

A conversational response may sound confident without having sufficient information about a person’s income, financial obligations, tax position, risk tolerance or long-term objectives. The user may also be unaware of the assumptions behind a recommendation.

There is a behavioural dimension here: people may place undue confidence in an automated recommendation, particularly when it is presented in a personalised and conversational format.

AI should therefore be understood as a potential research and decision-support tool, not automatically as a substitute for regulated financial advice or independent judgement.

The central question is not simply whether AI can answer financial questions. It is whether people can assess the quality, limitations and suitability of the answers they receive.

6. The institutional dimension: Who is responsible for digital financial wellbeing?

As payments and consumer decisions become more digital, financial wellbeing cannot be treated exclusively as an individual responsibility.

Consumers need the knowledge and skills to use digital payment systems safely. But institutions and platforms also have responsibilities concerning transparency, security, fair design and consumer protection.

The OECD’s 2025 policy brief, Supporting Informed and Safe Use of Digital Payments Through Digital Financial Literacy, highlights this challenge.

It reports that in 2024, 96% of individuals across OECD countries made or received a digital payment. Yet across 39 economies, 40% of adults who bought goods and services online in 2023 did not reach the minimum target for digital financial literacy used in the survey.

The OECD identifies both the benefits and risks of digital payments, including convenience, financial inclusion, overspending, fraud, scams, phishing and data theft.

This is an important distinction: participation in a digital financial system does not necessarily mean that someone has the knowledge required to navigate every risk within it.

Regulation is also evolving.

On 11 November 2026, the European Commission adopted a proposal for a Digital Fairness Act. The proposal addresses practices including manipulative design, addictive features, unfair personalisation, overspending incentives, misleading pricing and difficulties managing or cancelling digital contracts.

At the time of writing, this is a legislative proposal, not an enacted regulation. Its significance lies in the policy direction: digital consumer protection is increasingly concerned with how commercial environments are designed and how those environments influence behaviour.

Financial wellbeing in a digital economy therefore involves several interconnected responsibilities:

  • Individuals need digital and financial literacy to understand transactions, commitments and risks.
  • Financial institutions need to provide clear information and appropriate safeguards.
  • Digital platforms need to consider the effects of their commercial and interface design.
  • Policymakers and regulators need to ensure that consumer protection evolves alongside technology.

The objective is not to restrict innovation or remove convenience. It is to create an environment in which consumers can benefit from digital services while retaining meaningful control over their decisions.

7. The gender and economic agency dimension

The abstraction of money also raises questions about women’s financial agency.

Women’s economic circumstances are not uniform. Income, employment, household responsibilities, career interruptions, financial knowledge, access to technology and life transitions can all influence financial decisions.

Digital payments can offer important benefits. They can facilitate access to financial services, simplify transactions, support people managing finances across locations and provide greater flexibility in everyday economic life.

At the same time, digital financial participation requires more than access to a payment method.

It involves understanding transaction costs, managing recurring commitments, protecting personal data, recognising financial risks and evaluating the information presented by digital platforms.

The growing use of AI for financial guidance adds another consideration.

The 2026 South Korean study discussed earlier found higher LLM use for financial tasks among men than women in its sample. This does not establish why the difference exists, nor does it demonstrate that women are less capable or less interested in using AI. It does, however, raise questions about differences in adoption, access, confidence and the use of emerging financial technologies.

For women navigating career changes, relocation, changing household responsibilities or new financial opportunities, the ability to understand and manage digital financial systems can be particularly relevant.

The objective should not be to encourage women simply to spend less. It should be to strengthen their capacity to make informed financial decisions, retain income, manage commitments and direct resources towards their own priorities.

Financial agency includes the ability to question the systems in which financial decisions take place.

8. Making money visible: From awareness to financial agency

Digital payments are part of everyday economic life. There is little reason to assume that consumers should abandon them or return to cash in order to manage their finances effectively.

The more useful response is to develop systems that restore awareness and intentionality to digital transactions.

Make transactions visible. Review account activity regularly. Do not rely exclusively on the balance displayed in a banking application. Understand what has been spent, what remains committed and what is available.

Examine recurring payments. Review subscriptions, automatic renewals, instalments and other recurring commitments. Consider their cumulative impact rather than evaluating each payment in isolation.

Understand the full cost. When using credit or instalment arrangements, examine the total repayment obligation, fees, interest where applicable and payment dates.

Introduce deliberate pauses. For non-essential purchases, allow time to consider whether the purchase is aligned with your priorities. Convenience does not require immediate action.

Question the design. Notice how platforms present offers, defaults, prices and cancellation options. Ask whether the information is clear and whether you have a genuine opportunity to compare alternatives.

Use AI thoughtfully. AI can help explain financial concepts, organise research and explore scenarios. Check important information against reliable sources, understand the assumptions involved and seek qualified professional advice where the decision requires it.

Connect spending with financial goals. Review how current commitments affect the money available for emergency reserves, investment, business development and other longer-term priorities.

These practices are not about making every purchase difficult. They are about ensuring that the ease of a transaction does not replace awareness of its financial consequences.

From the abstraction of money to the ownership of wealth

The way we pay influences the experience of spending. The design of digital environments can shape the choices we encounter. Algorithms influence what we see, while artificial intelligence is changing how we access and interpret financial information.

These developments make financial management more complex, but they also make financial awareness more important.

Understanding money in a digital economy requires more than knowing how to use a payment application. It requires an understanding of the psychological, technological, commercial and institutional systems that influence financial decisions.

For WEMATTER, this is an essential part of the KEEP conversation.

Keeping more of what we earn is not simply a matter of controlling expenditure. It also involves understanding how spending decisions are shaped, recognising the commitments we take on and ensuring that the systems we use support our financial priorities.

Because money may be increasingly abstract, but the choices it makes possible are very real.

Financial agency begins when we understand not only how we use money, but also the systems that influence how we decide to use it.


Sources and Further Reading

Behavioural economics and payment mechanisms

Prelec, D. and Loewenstein, G. (1998). “The Red and the Black: Mental Accounting of Savings and Debt.” Marketing Science, 17(1), 4–28. https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.17.1.4

Soman, D. (2001). “Effects of Payment Mechanism on Spending Behavior: The Role of Rehearsal and Immediacy of Payments.” Journal of Consumer Research, 27(4), 460–474. https://doi.org/10.1086/319621

Schomburgk, L., Belli, A. and Hoffmann, A. O. I. (2024). “Less Cash, More Splash? A Meta-Analysis on the Cashless Effect.” Journal of Retailing, 100(3), 382–403. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretai.2024.05.003

Digital financial literacy and consumer protection

OECD (2025). Supporting Informed and Safe Use of Digital Payments Through Digital Financial Literacy. OECD Publishing, Paris. https://doi.org/10.1787/21de47d1-en

European Commission (2024). Digital Fairness Fitness Check of EU Consumer Law. European Commission.

European Union (2022). Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Digital Services Act, Article 25: Online interface design and organisation. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2022/2065/oj

European Commission (2026). Proposal for a Digital Fairness Act, COM(2026) 1100 final, 11 November 2026.

Artificial intelligence and personal finance

Pak, T.-Y. (2026). “How Individuals Use Generative AI for Personal Financial Management.” Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 49, Article 101145. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbef.2026.101145

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share:

More Posts

The Opportunity Cost of Being a Woman

The opportunity cost of being a woman is staggering. Consider the hours spent on unpaid domestic responsibilities, caregiving, household management and the invisible work of keeping families and households functioning.

Send Us A Message